07-16-2005, 09:44 PM
these guys should have recieved jail time .
the man has a right to belong to the * church of satan * as well as any other church he chooses , and the govt( judge ) has a obligation to defend that right without predudice or personal opinion . t
If they had attacked a african american because he was differant from them the ACLU would have been all over the press demanding the stiffest sentance possible ..
It seems also the ACLU are not interested unless the person attacked is of the A/A race . and attacked by cuacasion .
fine policy for a charity based org that fights for the rights of All
sensitivity training indeed ..... would he have passed the same sentance had the youths attacked a christian cus he was differant or a A/A ??? .
articule from court tv copied below ......
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
attack agree to plea deal
Paul Rotondi and Frank Scarpinito were facing hate crime charges for beating up a self-described member of the Church of Satan
NEW YORK — Two New York teens avoided jail time for attacking a self-proclaimed "card-carrying" member of the Church of Satan by pleading guilty Tuesday to second-degree assault as a hate crime.
Against the objections of prosecutors, Queens Supreme Court Justice James Griffin sentenced Paul Rotondi, 18, and Frank Scarpinito, 18, to 150 hours of community service and five years' probation for the Jan. 9 attack on Daniel Romano in Maspeth, Queens, a quiet suburb of New York City.
Queens District Attorney Richard Brown recommended three and a half years in prison for the defendants, who faced potential 15-year sentences on five counts, including aggravated assault and use of a weapon in the supposedly Satanism-biased attacks.
"The defendants have ... acknowledged that they harassed, attacked and physically injured the victim because he was different from them," Brown said in a press release.
Prosecutors said that on Jan. 9 at about 230 p.m., the defendants called out "Hey, Satan," to Romano from a car before getting out and beating him with an ice scraper and metal pipe.
Romano sustained multiple bruises and lacerations and was treated for 12 stitches in the back of his head.
At the time of the assault, prosecutors noted, Romano was wearing black nail polish and an upside-down crucifix, and his hair was dyed blue.
Scarpinito's attorney, Richard Leff, concedes that his client attacked Romano, but denied the incident was motivated by anti-Satanism sentiment.
"The D.A. may call this a hate crime, but really, it's just a case of some kids acting dumb and beating up another kid who was a bit of an oddball," Leff said.
The charges cast unwanted media attention on the Manhattan-based Church of Satan, whose high priest, Peter Gilmore, attempted to distance Romano from the organization in several interviews.
Satanists consider themselves "the most formidable threat to those who would halt progress in the name of spirituality," according to a Web site, describing its members as "explorers on the untrodden paths of science, human motivation and mystery — all that is most truly occult."
Founded in 1966, the Church of Satan "holds individualism as one of its main values," according to its Web site, and cautions outsiders that they won't find group hugs "as part of the repertoire."
Conspicuously absent on the Web site are references to human sacrifices or other misperceptions of the religion that prosecutors say sparked the attack on Romano, who claims to hold the Church of Satan's "Red Card" of membership.
The defendants will begin their community service immediately and will return in front of Justice Griffin on Oct. 11, when he will formally vacate their plea as youth offenders and impose the five years' probation, considering their progress.
"The judge evidently thought that what they needed was sensitivity training," said Leff. "This way, they do good deeds and help out society a bit
the man has a right to belong to the * church of satan * as well as any other church he chooses , and the govt( judge ) has a obligation to defend that right without predudice or personal opinion . t
If they had attacked a african american because he was differant from them the ACLU would have been all over the press demanding the stiffest sentance possible ..
It seems also the ACLU are not interested unless the person attacked is of the A/A race . and attacked by cuacasion .
fine policy for a charity based org that fights for the rights of All
sensitivity training indeed ..... would he have passed the same sentance had the youths attacked a christian cus he was differant or a A/A ??? .
articule from court tv copied below ......
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
attack agree to plea deal
Paul Rotondi and Frank Scarpinito were facing hate crime charges for beating up a self-described member of the Church of Satan
NEW YORK — Two New York teens avoided jail time for attacking a self-proclaimed "card-carrying" member of the Church of Satan by pleading guilty Tuesday to second-degree assault as a hate crime.
Against the objections of prosecutors, Queens Supreme Court Justice James Griffin sentenced Paul Rotondi, 18, and Frank Scarpinito, 18, to 150 hours of community service and five years' probation for the Jan. 9 attack on Daniel Romano in Maspeth, Queens, a quiet suburb of New York City.
Queens District Attorney Richard Brown recommended three and a half years in prison for the defendants, who faced potential 15-year sentences on five counts, including aggravated assault and use of a weapon in the supposedly Satanism-biased attacks.
"The defendants have ... acknowledged that they harassed, attacked and physically injured the victim because he was different from them," Brown said in a press release.
Prosecutors said that on Jan. 9 at about 230 p.m., the defendants called out "Hey, Satan," to Romano from a car before getting out and beating him with an ice scraper and metal pipe.
Romano sustained multiple bruises and lacerations and was treated for 12 stitches in the back of his head.
At the time of the assault, prosecutors noted, Romano was wearing black nail polish and an upside-down crucifix, and his hair was dyed blue.
Scarpinito's attorney, Richard Leff, concedes that his client attacked Romano, but denied the incident was motivated by anti-Satanism sentiment.
"The D.A. may call this a hate crime, but really, it's just a case of some kids acting dumb and beating up another kid who was a bit of an oddball," Leff said.
The charges cast unwanted media attention on the Manhattan-based Church of Satan, whose high priest, Peter Gilmore, attempted to distance Romano from the organization in several interviews.
Satanists consider themselves "the most formidable threat to those who would halt progress in the name of spirituality," according to a Web site, describing its members as "explorers on the untrodden paths of science, human motivation and mystery — all that is most truly occult."
Founded in 1966, the Church of Satan "holds individualism as one of its main values," according to its Web site, and cautions outsiders that they won't find group hugs "as part of the repertoire."
Conspicuously absent on the Web site are references to human sacrifices or other misperceptions of the religion that prosecutors say sparked the attack on Romano, who claims to hold the Church of Satan's "Red Card" of membership.
The defendants will begin their community service immediately and will return in front of Justice Griffin on Oct. 11, when he will formally vacate their plea as youth offenders and impose the five years' probation, considering their progress.
"The judge evidently thought that what they needed was sensitivity training," said Leff. "This way, they do good deeds and help out society a bit